|
too thin?
Ok so a lot of people tell me i am too thin. I've done those online calculators and they say i am, but you can't really trust those things because they don't take in to consideration a lot of important factors, you know. So, I thought if people could look at my pic site and give me their honest opinion? Thanks. [Link](Mouse over link to see full location)
[ ]
Want to answer more questions in the Health & Fitness category?
Maybe give some free advice about: Nutrition?
yourr sucking in, when i suck in thats what it looks like, your fine...
not anorexic just attention hungryy
]
rate me what you wish, but i personally think that it looks like you are sucking in, in the pictures of course.
as for your size? yeah, you're petite.
go to a doctor if you feel it neccessary.
]
Oh wow, these pictures made me cry. I feel that way because I haven't really seen anyone like that before. It scares me(and I'm not trying to say that you're weird or anything.) Please, please, please see a doctor. I'm pretty sure that you're a beautiful girl and with help you could be even more beautiful. I really am going to pray for you and I hope that everything goes well. Sweetheart if you need to talk to someone and you have AIM, my screen name is iitsyagiirlSASHA. PLEASE feel free to talk to me if you need something.
--SASHA:)
]
...
]
I think you are a beatuful person and u are having the same problems as me so my opionion is grow just a little more weight not much just a little and show people that u are a realy beatuful person inside.
]
yes u r really skiny why dont you just get junk food and eat alot of choclate so you will get fatter
]
honestly, u are too skinny
theres nothing wrong with being trim
but you might even be annorexic
i suggest you see a doctor
at this point you might not be able to help yourself
good luck <3
]
You know, there isn't much advice I can really give you. I suggest you go see a doctor immediately and ask him questions that you've wondered about. That's all I can say, because I'm not a professional. Good luck, sweety. ♥
]
oh my goodness that is way too thin you may need to gain at least 15 pounds, when u start seeing your ribs even stick out a little it means your thing enough!
]
There are a million different reasons why you could be that thin.
Some people have an eating disorder, some people have a health problem, etc.
But it all comes down to the same thing, too skinny.
I almost didn't answer your question because so many people have answered and I saw that you were rating people 1s because they told you, you were too skinny. I understand its not the way to go to tell you, some people were mean about it, but I hope that you gain something from all these people answering.
First off you should probably talk to a parent. Then consult a nutritionist to give you the information you need to start gaining some weight. Hopefully that will get you on the right track to being a healthy wieght. Good luck.
]
You definately need to get help from a doctor. It's not a good thing for your ribs to stick out...especially that far!
]
I am so sorry to say it, but you are. Having your ribs sticking out like that is not healthy. My advice is, if you already don't, eat food with more carbs and calories. If you go to a nutritionaist that can help you choose the right diet that will put some weight on you. also going to the gym to work on getting some musle will make you look less skinny. People tell me all the time if i didn't play sports and work out i would be so skinny. So i hope i have answered this question for you, and i hope you will take some advice. Because there was a kid in my neighbrohod who was skinny like that and she had to go to the hospital, and i don't want that to happen to anyone. So hope you get better!
]
omg. im the same way. i went to a doctor and he told me that i need to eat more and if i dont start gaining weight, then hes gonna have to either do injections or put me on medication that would slow my metabolism. its not healthy. so, please, see a doctor. or someone else who can help.
]
your extremly skinny. im not trying to sound rude but you could stand to gain 10 pounds. i really hope you dont think your fat. being that skinny isnt healthy or very attractive im not saying your ugly or anything like that or to gain three hundred pounds but 5 or ten pounds more would be a plus for your situation.have you tried protein bars or maybe you should eat more if you eat normal you could just have an extremly fast matabalism in that case get with a doctor.they can probably give you some weight advice. theres nothing wrong with being skinny but your ribs poking out is not appealing or sexy,i dont mean to be offensive.
]
Okay you are really skinny. And that might not be your fault. We don't know what your eating habits are or anything. Maybe you need to eat more, or maybe you just might have something where you are just naturally skinny. Either way talk to a doctor, see what the doctor says.
]
Hey there!
Omgosh, those pictures made me feel really bad.
Yes hun, i'm sorry but that is to skinny.
I'm not trying to be mean at all, because I have friends like this, and I love them to death.
But I think that you should go to a doctor and see what they can do for you.
Wow omgosh, no matter if a guy thinks its sexy or not, don't listen to them it's not, I feel so sad :[
Please get better!!!
Hope I helped.
-Brittany. :]
]
you need to talk to a relative and then maybe the doctor
]
You Definitely are too skinny. I really think you should seek medical help asap. If something is causing you to stop eating or to feel badd you need to see a therapist. Talk to a trusted adult on a daily basis as well. As you can see a LOT of people have answered your question, so please get better and let us know when you have. :)
]
omg hunny yes you are! i really do;t know how else to put it. u should see a doctor as soon as possible. i only have your best intrest at heart.
]
please don't take this offensively. but you know how you think you are too fat??? you should be thinkin that you are too thin. you may have tried to lose weight to look better, but it doesn't help to do it the way you did. i am sure you are a beautiful girl. you just need someone to tell you that without you fishing for compliments. gain some weight back. i know i weigh more than you. trust me. but i am a very thin person. i am happy with my weight. remember tho... muscle weighs more than fat.
i know you are beautiful inside. and i'm sure your beautiful outside too. look at those pics, you have beautiful clear skin! lol. work with that and gain back some weight. maybe go talk to a friend or a counselor
i have faith in you.
god loves you no matter how much u weigh
]
You are very thin, and it appears to be dangerously thin. You need to safely put on weight, small bits at a time, small steps. You need body fat. When you dont have enough body fat you can have poor circulation, trouble conceiving, and a lot more. It might be helpful to see a nutritionist about healthy eating habits to gain some fat and muscle.
Good luck!
]
yes, your thin. very thin. try to put on some weight..but not to fast or you will get sick.
I HOPE ALL THIS ADVICE UR GETTING HELPS U NOTICE!
PLEASE DONT LET IT GET TO DRASTIC!
GOOD LUCK
-ASHLEY
]
Yeah, you are deffinatly way too skinny. You're skin and bones, seriously. That's very unhealthy. I think you should see a docter and get put on a special diet..you may have a disease where you cannot gain weight so it's very important to see the docter. Good luck to you hun. ♥
XxEmo_HelpxX
]
omg omg omg. i almost threw up looking at your pictures. =((( seriously no offence. do you know how many people on here care about you right now? you have ***58*** answeres to your question! i think thats the most that advicenators ever had to a question! and when you go to www.advicenators.com, at the way top it says answer this question and you may save someones life with your opinion and it is your question! please listen to me. you are dieing. please please eat. please im begging you. did your parents ever mention anything to you???? please just eat and see a doctor before its too late. trust me if you don't get treated, i guarentee you that you will die. please dont worry about being skinny if that is your problem. i really really really hope that your not anorexic or bullimic.(sp?) i wish the best best luck to you.
[Link](Mouse over link to see full location)
xo melissa
]
you asked for my honest opinion,
and that is your way too skinny.
i highly doubt it's your fault though.
so the people saying things like "get help you have an eating disorder!" need to stop.
because i doubt you have one or you would have mentioned it.
some people are just like that and that's the way they are.
however, i really suggest you go to a doctor.
because if you wait and don't go right away it could be too late.
another honest opinion is i would really hate to see you die from something like this.
doctors will really help you fix things like this though.
and they will let you know FOR SURE if you're too skinny
+ if you are they'll help you gain weight the healthy way. (not through fatty foods)
i hope everything works out for you
+ give me feedback on what happens after you go to the doctor. (if you do)
]
Ohmigosh!
Not to be like...rude or anything but you are uber small.
Like...there is no way that you are healthy.
Please see somebody about it.
Aren't your parents worried?
I hope everything is okay with you.
XOXO
]
yes. you are definately too skinny. please. please. please. get help. i don't know if you're anorexic or not but there's definately something wrong. it might not be your fault. but PLEASE get help. until you go to the doctor...eat lots of fatty food. eat chocolate, chips, anything else you can think of.
PLEASE GET HELP!
]
i know a lot of people tell you are too thin,and most people did on here,but its really what you think- do you think your too thin? really,in anyone if you can see the ribs and your rib cage all the way,are are quite thin.its okay for bones to stick out a little but it isnt exactly good to see your whole bones.i dont think you have a eating disorder,you would've mentioned it. are you really stressed lately? maybe you dont notice you haven't been eating cause your sad or something along those lines. deffinalty a doctor would help you,because truthfully really know one knows whats happening.tell your mother,and the doctor can hopefully tell you the cause
goodluck!
xkisakissx
]
Hi!
I went to school with a girl who was ALMOST as skinny as you, and the people who are saying you are anorexic/bulemic or whatever should know that isn't the only reason for something like this.
Kim had a very bad parasite problem. i don't remember the name of the parasite, but it made her look like you.
The parasite eats most of the food the you put in your body and doesn't leave enough for you to live on, so your body has to basically eat itself to stay alive.
You asked for honest opinions:
i don't care why you look like you do, i really dont.
You are far too thin to be healthy. Your body is eating itself just to stay alive.
Kim lost so mush heart muscle that she almost died.
You are skinnier than she EVER was, even right before she collapsed and almost died.
it took her YEARS to recover and she still cant play sports or anything because of her heart.
Please listen! You are WAY thinner than she was and she ALMOST DIED!
PLEASE! See a nutritionist and tell them you think you might have a parasite problem because you DON'T have an eating disorder.
Even if you DID have an eating disorder this will let you see a doctor without having to admit it.
You cannot lose by seeing a doctor. You will die if you do not see one. :'(
you make me cry cause i think of kim almost dead, and how much worse you look than she did.
PLEASE I am BEGGING YOU!
pls leave me fb afteryou have seen a doctor and had the parasite test.
]
i'm so scared for you right now, i'm actually crying. hunny, you need to get help. i saw those pictures, and i think you may have anorexia. please, please go see a doctor as soon as possible. you could die from this disease, from malnutrition and other causes. please, do it for me , do it for yourself. you can't really go by those BMI calculators, because they just aren't very acurate. please, go to a doctor, or to the hospital.
god bless,
xo
yes, actually i was, i'm very emotional like that, and i said you may have anorexia, not you do
]
You are really too thin. You can see your bones! My advice for you would be to seek medical help, as soon as possible! Good luck!
]
I just wanted to put some input on this because everyone is saying- oh go see a doctor which is somewhat true if you have an eating disorder.
when people see others that are extremely skinny they obviously asume they are anorexic, bulimic, on drugs, ect. those are diseases(you probably know that) and take a while to overcome and maybe seeing a therapist or your school counseler would make you feel better emotionally before changing the way you are physically but this may not be your situation.
however, if you have always been this thin then you would be going to the doctor for a different reason & they would do blood tests to find the cause, obviously i don't know what it could be.
i think that if you are thin because of something that isn't related to an eating disorder then go to the doctor right away.
]
you are way to thin you need to get help from a doctor and fast
ihope i helped
]
to be honest you are so skinny you should get like a doctor for that and tell him to get you something like to make you fatter there are drinks,chocolate bars with alot of protien, and HELPS alot my sister uses a drink equate and it helped her alot i hopei helped !
]
well to tell you the truth i think you are to skinny. if i were you i would tell my doctor and start to eat meat and a lot more often. i had an eating disorder to wen i was younger. if it gets serious you can end up in the hospital so i would consider eating more food but balancing it out with healty food. ask your doctor to make a nutritional food list.
Thats all i can say
I hoped i helped
*flaggal*
]
ok wat is that a picture of? from that picture, you are too thin. its also your opinion if your too fat or skinny. this is just advice you can CHOOSE to follow or not. its your body.
hope i helped and good luck!
]
I don't mean to bring down your self esteem or anything, but it appears that you have gotten to the point where you are underweight and it could be dangerous to your health. If you are naturally skinny, its going to be hard to gain the weight needed but i think it is necessary. If you have an eating disorder, it is very important that you see a doctor, pehaps a specialist.
Some dangers to your health if you continue like this is insufficent amounts of iron and calcium, infertility, bone loss, low blood pressure, and more.
If you do have an eating disorder, go here: [Link](Mouse over link to see full location)
]
You are way to skinny please see a doctor as soon as possible and try to eat more!!
]
holy crap. skinnnyyyyyyyyyyy. way too skinny.
]
being this thin is not healthy.
a smart choice would be to go see a doctor after telling your family and friends about this.
]
You are wayyy to skinny! You should go see a doctor, theres a problem with being that skinny.
]
You are really super thin.
Way way to thin, it looks so dangerous!
I hope your heath is doing okay.
Please go see a medical physician.
please! Its so important, just eating a lot of food wont help, you need to see a doctor.
]
You are dangerously thin. You may have an eating disorder or a medical issue. please seek medical attention before it's too late.
good luck =]
]
I agree with you when it comes to thouse BMI calculators being wrong but after looking over your pictures you look way to much thin to me. You need to eat something and make sure its way junky so you can get some meat on your bones
]
You are too thin.
Please, please get help as soon as possible. Tell your parents, tell your friends, go and see a doctor. Please.
]
Yeah, you're much too thin. The BMI calculator is inaccurate for people that weigh more, not for people who weigh less. Believe it. Stop looking in the mirror and looking at pictures. They mean nothing. I saw a show on TV once where Paula Abdul was talking about overcoming anorexia in her life. Whether you have an eating disorder or are for some reason as naturally thin as you are, what she had to say can still help you answer your question for yourself. If you aren't entirely sure that you are too thin, you have a distorted body image. This isn't weird or anything. Tons of people have it. I would go as far to say that almost everyone goes through at least some time in their life where they do. I certainly have. Anyways, one of the things that Paula did that helped a lot to get over her distorted body image was to have a friend trace her on a piece of paper. In that way, she was able to look at herself outside of herself. Normally, when you look at yourself, you are looking down at your body, in a mirror, or at a picture. None of these are a good representation of your true size. When you look down at yourself you can't see everything. Your stomach looks like it sticks out more than it really does and since your eyes are so close to you body, every imperfection is magnified. When you look in the mirror your body keeps in proportion, but it is smaller than the true size of your body because you have to stand away from the mirror to look. It is also just a 2D image. In pictures, there is no way to determine how big you are and pictures too, are only 2D. You can never look at yourself in the same way as you look at other people. It would be wonderful if you could, but sadly, you can't step outside of yourself and take a peek. Having someone trace you is the closest thing to that. You'll look at the outline of yourself and you'll realize how tiny you actually are. It will probably surprise you and maybe even scare you. You need to see a doctor as soon as you can. It's very hard to treat what you have and the longer you wait the more danger you are in. You could die! :(
Please get help. Good luck.
]
The BMI calculators just go by basic information, but they give you a place to start. If they say you are underweight, then you need to see a physician who can determine if there is a problem.
You want our opinions, but if you honestly have anorexia, you are not going to believe you are too thin no matter what we say. You need professional help, and not opinions from a message board.
]
I think you are way too thin. it's not healthy or attractive. eat please... i wouldn't want you to die from this! <3
]
You are very, very thin. Honestly, I don't think that it looks very good.
]
i dont even know you and you have me worried! if you want me to be honest that i will. you nees to put on wait. your way to thin to me. eat eat and eat. please. you may not be able to trust the things online but from what your pictures say you need to put on weight. please. work on it. all i can tell you id to eat. just eat. and go from there. i hope everything works out and please be carful you should talk to a doctor to just to make sure its nothing serious. hope i helped and feel free to email me anytime to ask a question. good luck.
]
your asking me to be honest, so here it is: you need to gain some weight. for a basic rule of thumb: if your ribs stick out more than an inch you're too thin. i know that everybody is telling you to go to the doctor, which is a good idea, but if you don't want to go to the doctor then just start eating more. RIGHT AWAY! if you keep getting thinner then you will just become even more unhealthy. you don't want to have to go to the hospital and get fed by a tube do you? yeah i didn't think so. if you are anorexica, which i'm not saying you are, but just if you are then just slowly start to eat more food. i know that it would be hard to start eating a lot right away, so just slowly work your way into eating three full meals a day.
i really hope you take some of my advice and the advice of others into account and do something for yourself <3
]
Ok you are VERY thin and i doubt it is healthy. really you need to eat more. Seeing a doctor might help to! Hope i helped<333
Liz
]
you are WAY too thin. please talk to your mom or dad and get help! you need to go to the doctor, and you need to start eating or you could die (know this sounds harsh but its true). please get help soon!
]
you can't really go by those BMI calculators, because they just aren't very acurate.
but by looking at your pictures, you are incredibly thin.
i don't know if this is what you want, but in my opinion, it doesn't look healthy.
maybe a doctor could help?
]
Hunn you are too thin. Please eat some more, go see a doctor. Something. I can't even tell what part of your body that is.
]
I'd have to say that you're very thin, and probably very underweight. I'd reccomend seeing a doctor or nutritionalist, so that you can gain some weight, and check if your metabolism is overactive or something.
Kat
]
Girl you need to get some meat on them bones. Honestly you are too too skinny. If I were you in this case, believe the calculators.People who are too thin end up getting sick and end up possibly having health issues.
]
Yes you are thin. I am too and i eat normal,exercise and do normal things. Its okay that your thin as long as your not anorexic/bulimic/or have an eating disorder then dont worry! Those sites tell me that im underweight and my doctors do to! You just have a high metabolism. Just eat healthy and exercise and you'll be fine :0) Or ask your doctor if your worried.
]
oooooohhhk. you areeee reeaally thin to the point where it mite not be healthy. i suggest asking your doctor.
]
wow, you are hella thin its not healthy i no u didnt do it but i think you need to go like to see a doctor or go to the hospital so they can make it so your not skinny. hope it helps
~trisha~
]
You're too thin. See a doctor and find a good nutritional and exercise plan that works for you.
]
Girl....Please E...A.....T! I was once into anorexia and I was very thin myself but you have to eat. You're Malnourished and that if taken too far can eventually kill you and/or make you very sick. Not eating or being healthy eats away at your bone marrow and your body will disenigrate.
]
Are you trying to be this skinny or are you just naturally like that? Because if you are trying to be that skinny, and not eating alot and like dieting i would say stop because you dont need to be doing that. If anything you should be eating some more fatty'ish foods to gain some weight because right now your weight is deffinatly not healthy. But I think it also depends on how old you are. Because I used to be pretty skinny but once I hit 14 I started to shape out alittle and not be so bony(i got boobs too! a plus of having sum meat on your bones)
]
yea ur to skinny atleast ur stomache needs to match up to your hip bones and rib cage and your good. thats not healthy dear.
]
okay i have to say that you are very thin and that may not be healthy but there are things that you can do you should go to a doctor and let them talk to you (dont hold any info that might be needed)if anything let me know what happens and i will try to help you through this all the world needs is another nicole richie stuck in the hospital for not eating (i am not saying that you dont eat ) but i want to help.
]
If you aren't sucking your stomach in (it doesnt look like it but I could be wrong) then I have to agree with most everyone else. Its possible to be naturally thin, but you do indeed look, possibly, too much so.
I'd go see a doctor and be TOTALLY honest. Remember if you lie to a doctor, or omit importntt facts, you'll make it much harder for them to diagnose you correctly. If you eat very little, exercise a lot, anythign even remotely important, you would need to mention. Answer whatever is asked with complete honesty. That way the doctor will be able to take into everything into consideration and tell you if you are simply naturally very thin, or if you need to change your calorie intake, etc etc. I have to admit I've known people this thin /shrug. But I cannot tell from pictures if this is normal for you or not.
]
Honey, you are too thin. Eat a steak or something.. please. Just don't do this to yourself. Not to be rude, but go to a doctor. Make sure you're healthy and get help. It's for the best.
]
I would be very concerned for your health at this point. If you are eating normally and you figure is this frail and thin, I would truly recommend going to a doctor. Honestly, I have seen anorexic people before, and you are much thinner than they were. I have never seen anything like this before. Please arrange an appoint asap even if there is no eating problem. I agree that online calculators do not take factors in to consideration, so don't go by them. It would be to your benefit to go to a doctor because they are certified in this area.
]
your body would be called emaciated. it is extremely unhealthy. soon, if you have not already experienced this, your body will start breaking down what is left of your muscle cells, causing extreme pain. please, please, PLEASE see a doctor immediatly, before it is too late. this is a very serious condition. even though it might not seem so to you, your life is in grave danger.
]
Oh my god. Honey, you need to see a doctor right away. You look like someone in a concentration camp! It's extremely unhealthy and if you don't get help right away, you actually could die, not to mention that it would screw up your body forever- you might not ever be able to have kids.
]
Honest, honest opinion:
Looking at your pictures, yes you do look very thin and could be mistaken for someone with an eating disorder. To put it bluntly, if you feel you aren't eating enough, I would definitely see a doctor. Even if you think everything is okay, still see one. Deep down, you know something isn't right or you wouldn't let us decide if you are thin for you.
Don't put your health at risk. Just go and check you are healthy and everything is working fine. :)
]
eat, please.
]
im gonna put this as simple as i can:
GO SEE A DOCTOR YOU ARE TOO THIN.
]
Yes, those BMI calculators actually aren't very accurate but they come pretty close.
And yes, you are very skinny. I'm surprised no one has offered to take you to a doctor yet. You need to talk to one right a way to take care of it, you might have a special condition that you're unaware of and you need to address it right away.
Please go see a doctor ASAP.
]
Hello there,
Looking at the provided pictures makes me wonder how you are still alive. :-(
Please understand that I am concerned for you. You are so thin that your body will have no choice but to use your muscles and other vital tissues to live on.
If you are eating a normal amount, not normal for you, but normal as in for your age and height, then it is possible you have a parasite problem, a glandular dysfunction, or an advanced form of some serious illness.
You need to see a doctor without delay.
Am I serious? Let me explain exactly what I thought when I saw your pix: "I have seen pictures from the Nazi death camps of World War II... and some of those people were healthier than this poor girl!"
I hope you will take this to heart, pick up the phone and make an appointment with your doctor.
You aren't just skinny, you are in desperately bad health, please seek help before your body is totally destroyed.
By the way, the BMI calculator you were talking about, always errs on the side of skinny, so if it said you were underweight, you should believe it.
Please leave a feedback comment when you have seen your doctor, and let me know how you do.
DN.
]
When your ribs are sticking out.. you're dangerously too thin.
You need to go see a doctor.
~
You asked for an honest opinion so I don't understand the whole rating of a 1.
Because you either have an eating disorder or something.. but you are too thin and it can effect your health. :
]
That appears to be your ribs sticking out, so yes I'd say you are WAY too thin.
]
Honey, you are way too thin. You can see your ribs! I suggest you go on a diet to help gain wieght. gO to a doctor and ask them for a healthy diet to help you gain the amount of wieht you need.
]
More Questions: |