Siren_Cytherea answered Sunday May 9 2010, 7:30 pm: If I have to choose between those two, Christina by far. Christina has a huge range and a hugely powerful voice. Britney has a pretty decent pop voice, but she sticks to pretty much one octave, which doesn't impress me in the least. They both use auto-tune, I'm sure, but Britney is more computerized than anything, I think. Christina uses more artistic and difficult techniques in her songs. It's pretty cool.
If I can go with option C, Amy Lee from Evanescence. She was classically trained and has a crazy powerful, soul-filled voice. She doesn't belt, she really SINGS. I love and respect it. She also writes her own songs, and she has one of the most hauntingly beautiful voices I've ever heard, and I'm a singer.
Matt answered Sunday May 9 2010, 6:02 am: Because I'm completely uninterested in whatever music is associated with them, I will instead focus on the aesthetic.
Now, when Britney was in her prime, she was hot as fuck. Ridiculously. When Christina was in her prime, she was a total slut. Which, in my opinion, was also hot as fuck. Which will bring us to today. Britney popped out a few kids and her entire aura of hotness vanished and was replaced with an overweight, slobby, I-don't-need-to-wear-shoes-in-this-public-restroom woman. When Christina popped out a kid, her boobs became moons and she, depending on your point of view, actually became hotter; it depends on whether you prefer slutty Christina or classy Christina, but in reality this is irrelevant because they're both really hot.
In conclusion, while it's a crapshoot as far as who was better in their respective primes, the modern day answer to your question is, by a landslide, Christina Aguilera. [ Matt's advice column | Ask Matt A Question ]
laynemayhem answered Sunday May 9 2010, 12:24 am: in my opinion, britney. i was never really a fan of hers, but ever since her breakdown she's been trying really hard to get back on her feet, and i think that takes a lot of guts. [ laynemayhem's advice column | Ask laynemayhem A Question ]
OhMyLucyDarling answered Sunday May 9 2010, 12:24 am: If I had to choose...
Fish answered Saturday July 3 2004, 11:53 pm: neither. They're both overrated. Apart from all the stupid frills (or lack thereof for that matter, Christina's got the better voice but I'm getting really sick of the falsetto trend. Oy, just pick one note and sing it. Quit sliding all up and down the scale already. [ Fish's advice column | Ask Fish A Question ]
bAhAmAmA0250 answered Saturday June 5 2004, 3:55 pm: Umm.. do i have to choose lol.. i guess they are honestly about the same.. they both are turning into sluts.. well they are both going for that look anyways.. so umm.. haha i cant decide thats like.. choosing whats better school or homework? they both suck! :) good example huh! xoxo trix [ bAhAmAmA0250's advice column | Ask bAhAmAmA0250 A Question ]
ncheer answered Thursday February 26 2004, 2:45 pm: i like them both the same. sometimes one will be a b**** and the other will be awesome. or one will have a good song and another will have a really crappy song, ext.
Here-To-Help answered Monday January 12 2004, 1:31 pm: Better how? Singing?...
Christina definitely.
But if your talking about whose prettier:
Britney is very pretty and so is Christina...but I think Britney is prettier. (if she didn't wear so much make-up).
And if your talking about anything after that:
I'm not going to answer whose got the better body because I'm not interested in girls...guys are where I am :p
Anonymousobserver answered Monday January 12 2004, 12:05 am: Neither. They are not musicians, they are well marketed products. Take my advice and listen to bands that don't have to take their clothes off to get people's attention, like Sleater Kinney or Something Corporate. [ Anonymousobserver's advice column | Ask Anonymousobserver A Question ]
Moop answered Thursday January 8 2004, 10:03 pm: Joni Mitchell could kick their asses any day of the week in a singing contest. [ Moop's advice column | Ask Moop A Question ]
nachoxqween answered Tuesday January 6 2004, 7:33 pm: Personally, I like Britney more. She doesn't dress as sleazy as Xtina, Brit has a more classy style. Xtina has a great voice, but she's just dissing everyone these days, including some of my favorite artists. [ nachoxqween's advice column | Ask nachoxqween A Question ]
Pyro answered Friday January 2 2004, 12:14 am: They both suck, but Christina has a much wider range and Britney has that annoying edge to her voice. [ Pyro's advice column | Ask Pyro A Question ]
xDarkorchid answered Monday December 15 2003, 10:12 pm: personally. i cant stand either of them.they both start out as young innocent people then they turn into major famous people..lose some clothing along the way.and then next thing you know thier making out at an award show. they belong "underground" [ xDarkorchid's advice column | Ask xDarkorchid A Question ]
Trueflight answered Monday December 15 2003, 1:29 pm: Well, the real issue is not who is better, but which one is less awful... I think they may well be at a standoff, but I'm just going to say Christina because her voice is miles less annoying. [ Trueflight's advice column | Ask Trueflight A Question ]
ScaperJess answered Saturday December 13 2003, 6:38 pm: Neither... the both can't sing great, both dress themselves far less than they should... and both I imagine are a dumb as a post... how can one be better when they both suck... But of course that is only my opinion... [ ScaperJess's advice column | Ask ScaperJess A Question ]
MFS answered Saturday December 13 2003, 1:54 am: Here's a more important question: Who cares?
Really, they are both mediocre, with moderate staying power. The only thing keeping their careers alive is the marketing of pop via the sex imagery.
Neither of the two are thought invoking. Neither of them push their craft in new directions. They are neither innovators or leaders. They are pawns of a dying industry.
People like to debate which one has the better voice... personally, I don't care for either. I know many singers who are far and away better tonally and stylistically. [ MFS's advice column | Ask MFS A Question ]
Joshua answered Saturday December 13 2003, 12:30 am: they both sell records through wearing almost no clothes and serve as horrific role models for young girls everywhere. yay. [ Joshua's advice column | Ask Joshua A Question ]
Turc answered Friday December 12 2003, 11:54 pm: Christina. She can actually sing.
It makes me sad, because when you see early tapes of Britney she has a good voice, but she's obviously not using it in her more recent work. :-P [ Turc's advice column | Ask Turc A Question ]
Attention: NOTHING on this site may be reproduced in any fashion whatsoever without explicit consent (in writing) of the owner of said material, unless otherwise stated on the page where the content originated. Search engines are free to index and cache our content. Users who post their account names or personal information in their questions have no expectation of privacy beyond that point for anything they disclose. Questions are otherwise considered anonymous to the general public.