Question Posted Wednesday December 15 2004, 7:40 pm
Hi I am christian, and I have a friend who is jewish. I want to get her a "holiday" present, but I am not sure what to call it, or if she would think it was rude. I am also not sure when i should give it to her. I don't know when haunaka is. What do you think?
TaTjEnJaMeS answered Saturday December 18 2004, 3:33 am: OOH I HAVE A JEWISH FRIEND TOO.. HER NAME IS KELLY WRIGHT =D Anywaayys.. you can get her something festive. Maybe go to a glass display thingy and buy a glass snowflake or snowman or something that has to do with Winter!! [ TaTjEnJaMeS's advice column | Ask TaTjEnJaMeS A Question ]
rainbowcherrie answered Friday December 17 2004, 11:15 am: Just get her the present and wrap it in normal wrapping paper, not christmas paper, and on the gift tag write: To (insert name) Happy holidays! From (insert name.) I'm sure she wouldn't be offended by that. [ rainbowcherrie's advice column | Ask rainbowcherrie A Question ]
msjb answered Thursday December 16 2004, 7:20 pm: haunaka has already past.. i think? and get her a christmaca present! or you could call it a holdiday present.. or a christmahanakwazakah present! But she would def. not be offended! Im sure everyone likes to get presents no matter what the holiday is. [ msjb's advice column | Ask msjb A Question ]
dancinqueen08 answered Thursday December 16 2004, 3:04 pm: I think you should talk to her about it. Everyone is different on how they feel about it. I have a jewish friend and I gave her a present and she didn't care, but others might not agree. Just see how she feels about it and go from there. [ dancinqueen08's advice column | Ask dancinqueen08 A Question ]
SoNuLiCiOuSsS answered Thursday December 16 2004, 1:09 pm: Well regardless of what you call it... i really doubt that shes going to get offended... but since u are concerned... why dont u not call it anything... just give it to her... & say "Happy Holidays" my friends & i arent christian... but we still exchange christmas presents... [ SoNuLiCiOuSsS's advice column | Ask SoNuLiCiOuSsS A Question ]
HuGzNKisSeZ69 answered Thursday December 16 2004, 1:01 pm: hannukah is going on right now but it will be over soon. So you can buy one now and give it to her. Of course she wouldn't fidn it offending on the card you could just write happy holidays an dhappy new year! i'm sure she would be flattered not think it was rude. you sound liek a great friend to consider all fo this [ HuGzNKisSeZ69's advice column | Ask HuGzNKisSeZ69 A Question ]
Pessy answered Thursday December 16 2004, 7:26 am: Call it a Chanukah present...as a Jew myself, I am flattered when my Christian friends ecknowledge the Jewish holiday. "Holiday" present sounds a bit ambigious...vague...but refurring to it as a Chanukah present shows that you respect their faith, sounds more warm. You know? [ Pessy's advice column | Ask Pessy A Question ]
AmericnJewl answered Thursday December 16 2004, 1:19 am: My best friend in college was Jewish and this is what I did. I would get her a "holiday" gift (just like you said) and wrapped it in either holiday neutral colors (you can find cute holiday gift bags at borders that are lime green or hot pink) or blue and silvers (the colors commonly associated with Hanukkah. I would deliver her gift some time between her holiday (which is different every year) and mine. This year Hanukka began on December 7th, according to the holiday site I give you below, it starts on December 25th next year.
bAhAmAmA0250 answered Thursday December 16 2004, 12:10 am: Just let her know that you dont know what to do but you'd like to get her a present and if she acts confused just let know that its just for the heck of it and haunaka i think is already over. I think it would be ok if you are good friends i would just talk to her about it and let her know where you are coming from i think it lasts 7 days though. 12/7-12/14 but put yourself in her shoes.. would you b mad if you got a simple present? [ bAhAmAmA0250's advice column | Ask bAhAmAmA0250 A Question ]
GroverTheStoNer answered Wednesday December 15 2004, 10:51 pm: Yeah you should totally give her a present! Don't even call it anything! Give it to her sometime before Christmas. Plan a gift exchange for both of you. I'm pretty sure it's going on now. And instead of giving those little Christmas tags on the presents, just get a piece of stationary and put, To: (Your Best Friend's Name), Love, (Your name). Happy Holidays!
*Randy T* [ GroverTheStoNer's advice column | Ask GroverTheStoNer A Question ]
XSugarPieX77 answered Wednesday December 15 2004, 10:08 pm: Hannukah has past already! But you can give her a Hannukah present still, just get her something that she likes like clothes or a CD or something...
~Brina~ [ XSugarPieX77's advice column | Ask XSugarPieX77 A Question ]
LAZYGIRL answered Wednesday December 15 2004, 9:59 pm: well i am christian 2 and i ahve a jewish friend, it doesn't matter what when you give it its just the thought that really counts!!! [ LAZYGIRL's advice column | Ask LAZYGIRL A Question ]
LoLo2454 answered Wednesday December 15 2004, 9:48 pm: Um...the last night of Chanukkah was last night...sorry. Just give her the gift and write on the card "Happy Holidays!" I have a bunch of Jewish friends and they are totally cool about it. No worries ;)
thpsmasta2k answered Wednesday December 15 2004, 9:34 pm: just give her a gift it doesn't have to be a "Christmas Present" or anything... you could just give her a gift and don't even tell her what kind it is ... but give it to her as soon as you can...so it does't look obvious... just tell her that you got her this gift to show her how mush you care for her and just drop it at that...
AsKmE135 answered Wednesday December 15 2004, 9:13 pm: I'm Jewish too. :-) And why would she get offended if you called it a "Holiday present?" Thats dumb. Just call it a Hanukkah present, there's nothing wrong with that. I mean, thats what it IS! And the last night of Hanukkah was Tuesday night (December 14) so you're a little bit late, but I'm sure she won't mind. A lot of my friends give me presents around christmas, because that's when they give all of their other friends presents, so im sure you friend is used to getting late Hanukkah presents. And as to what you should give her, just give her the same type of present as you should give one of your christian friends. You know, just like a cd or jewelry or a gift card or something. Jews are no different from christians when it comes to giving/recieving presents!! hope i helped! [ AsKmE135's advice column | Ask AsKmE135 A Question ]
truadvice answered Wednesday December 15 2004, 8:34 pm: well haunaka is over but you could still call it a haunaka present, you should just get her what you think she would like . [ truadvice's advice column | Ask truadvice A Question ]
Berri answered Wednesday December 15 2004, 8:27 pm: Hannakuh (sp.) is over, my dear friend. But if you still want to give her something for CHRISTMAS, I don't think it would be rude to. You can just say..."Hey! Happy Christmukkah!!!" Don't make a big deal out of it. Just tell her that you couldn't just NOT get her something. I don't think she'd mind. I mean hey, who doesn't like presents??? :P [ Berri's advice column | Ask Berri A Question ]
MACwh0re answered Wednesday December 15 2004, 8:23 pm: Give it to her this week and say "Hey ____, here is a gift for you for the holdiays. Hope you like it!" Call it a gift:) [ MACwh0re's advice column | Ask MACwh0re A Question ]
bff4eva answered Wednesday December 15 2004, 8:22 pm: Well Haunaka is over so you can't call it that. Try calling it a New Year's present or just a holiday present. Or maybe even say a late Haunaka present. I hope I helped! [ bff4eva's advice column | Ask bff4eva A Question ]
Attention: NOTHING on this site may be reproduced in any fashion whatsoever without explicit consent (in writing) of the owner of said material, unless otherwise stated on the page where the content originated. Search engines are free to index and cache our content. Users who post their account names or personal information in their questions have no expectation of privacy beyond that point for anything they disclose. Questions are otherwise considered anonymous to the general public.