ask TheOldOne



read advice get advice make favorite read feedback advicenators



I am no longer giving advice on Advicenators, and have requested that my account be deleted.

I am now giving advice on Askville as ->Peter

If you're looking for good advice here, I suggest you ask YoungGrandma. She's the best.

I don't expect to be checking in on this site again, so if you want to ask me something, see you on Askville!

Good luck!
Website: The Diary of An Invisble Man
E-mail: pmaranci@gmail.com
Gender: Male
Location: Rhode Island, USA
Occupation: Network Analyst
Member Since: July 22, 2005
Answers: 659
Last Update: May 14, 2006
Visitors: 72374

Main Categories:
Health
Spirituality
Random Weirdos
View All

Favorite Columnists
DangerNerd
Erinn_the_bamf
selectopaque
Siren_Cytherea
durgahelps
rainbowcherrie
S_C
jean_nicole
cailoisa
K2204
lucretia
more...
is it posible to prove that you exist? and i mean "exist" not "are alive".

if yes please do so couze this dam question is anoying me, its stuck in my head

and yes i know its a philosophical question that may not have a right or wrong answer but still (link)
As Saint Gasoline pointed out, "Cogito ergo sum".

But even though you are directly experiencing your own thought process (which I'd think would be pretty good evidence that "you" exist), you seem to doubt it.

So let me put it this way: there's a pretty simple duality here. Either you exist, in which case your question has meaning; or you don't exist, in which case you're nothing more than a chemical machine, and the question is totally meaningless.

But you chose to ASK that question. Which implies that you believe that you DO exist, since otherwise there's no point in asking anything at all.

Okay, granted, that's not an absolute proof that you exist. But you seem to be feeling some discomfort over the issue. Which is, I'd argue, another proof that you exist; I should look up the Latin for "I feel, therefore I am".

So presented with two possibilities, neither of which can be absolutely proven, it only makes sense to chose to believe the one that makes you happier. That way, even if you DON'T exist - even if you're just a machine of chemicals and atoms, following a predestined path - at least you'll be a HAPPIER machine.

Good luck!


Rating: 5
lol thanks, this question was just meant to see peoples opinion on the issue and to see how many ppl on here actualy know what they are talking about




read advice get advice make favorite read feedback advicenators

<<< Previous Advice Column
Next Advice Column >>>
humorist-workshop

eXTReMe Tracker