askRumely
advice column ask question view feedback favorite columnist advicenators

Q: Hello!..

So there is this chimney looking structure..in an empty field..that I go past to visit my boyfriend. I live in Cambridge, Ohio..and this is out..past where I live..

Well, I was watching this thing about adolf hitler and the concentration camps..and when they gased the jew's..in the chambers.. the fumes would come up out of the top of the chimney looking structures.. the same chimney looking structure..looks EXACTLY..like the one I seen.

I've always wondered what it is.. and now it makes me feel sick o.o..but I'm not sure if it really is.. or not..but why would it be there..alone..with nothing there with it?

It's mysterious.

If you can't help it's okay..but still..XD Thanks!
A chimney is a chimney, so they all tend to look similar. There were no concentration camps here where people were burned. We did have prison camps for POWs, but they did not include the atrocities of the concentration camps of the Nazi regime. There were interment camps for people of Japanese descent during WWII, citizens of our own country deprived of liberty and property simply because they were Japanese ethnically. Their treatment was unjust, but still didn't involve the atrocities of the Nazi concentration camps, or of the Japanese prison camps (the ones run by Japan, not the U.S. interment camps).

For some odd reason, it is not uncommon to find the ruins of a building where the chimney is left standing. That's all that remains of a brewery in New Ulm, Mn, for instance. Near where I live there is row of chimneys where there used to be, IIRC, a munitions plant; all the other structures are gone.

Q: Ok so one time.....i thought i was in luv.....i was in luv.... but one time we were with a group of friends and no one knew how i felt and how he said he felt....and he said in front of everyone that i liked him and he only pretended to like me and it waz all fake and he broke my heart and really embarrassed me and this was years ago.
Now i REALLY like this guy and we hang out a lot and talk and are really close friends and dont keep secrets from each other. I think he likes me bak and he has been giving lots of signs but he also has been giving lots of mixed signs, my friends and i and also some of his friends thinks he likes me but i am not sure.
I am afraid that if he ever asks me out or if he says he likes me and i say i like him bak, it would of been a joke or a dare from a friend so he would of made a big deal out of it or go off telling all his friends and embarrassing me because sometimes he is that sort of guy that makes big deals out of every thing or goes of telling his friends even though we are great friends too.
am i just afraid of telling people in after what happened or just feeling insecure.
Some of this is your paranoia from a past experience, and some of it is based on observations of how this guy behaves. That first guy you mentioned was a fool and a tool. He thought he was being clever and putting you down, but he was revealing the shallowness and untrustworthiness of his character. He demonstrated how small of a person he was. He basically showed all his friends that he was a fake, willing to use other people and hurt them for his own gratification, and that he could never be trusted. In truth, it was himself that he made a fool of.

The very nature of romantic relationships requires taking risks and being vulnerable. There is always the possibility of being hurt or embarrassed, but this can be minimized by taking the time to really get to know a guy, so see if he is a mature, safe, trustworthy, genuine person before pouring all your insides into his hands. What kind of friends does he hang out with and how does he treat them? This will give valuable clues as to how he is likely to treat you.

Q: I'm 18 i dont really have that much friends i have an attitude problem and might act a bit childish at times getting mad so easily but i dont hold grudges but i have more behavioral problems like the worst is talking and acting without thinking at most times which eventually call a thing where you get caught up with the situation thats usually how it is i still live with my family my mom still goes to me to school even thought im in college but thats because of the danger that i've been in before in my younger days they are worried that worse things might come so now im pretty much looking like im dependent on them to protect me. my friends they hate me for my attitude and say as thought and think that i am only using them im not really a people person im more of being the person who just waits till someone talks to me than me approching them so they hate that too sometimes i have fun with them but sometimes i dont, sometimes i feel as if i am left alone.....like they are the only ones involved and i am just set aside but they dont know or notice it they only think its because of my childish attitude that i act to stay away from them but it is infact that i felt that i am being pushed away they also try and change me to become independent but yet i dont feel as though i am ready yet i want to be but the feeling is like i am being forced into it makes it that i dont wanna go with it... so eventually they give up and say that they cant take it anymore that i am the bad guy i admit i might not be a person who you want to hang with but still i am not using anyone i treat them as my friends but its as if they can accept me for me but they have their own faults too and yet i am the only one who they hate i guess i dont really belong to this group im very negative so i am really losing hope and just want to stay away from them but is it really worth it cause there are consequences to this act i know i really need your advice please help me i would really appreciate it and be grateful

It is a good thing to become independent whether your friends are involved or not. You need to learn to approach life and relationships in a disciplined, focused way. You need to be proactive in your life, rather than being reactive. That means looking at where you want to go in life and making decisions and behaving in ways that will help you achieve those goals. You need to seek out friendships that are healthy (and it doesn't sound like your current friendships have a healthy dynamic). You need to think through the likely outcomes of your impulses and respond to them accordingly.

Find people who are succeeding in life, people who are doing well in their careers, professional relationships, personal relationships, etc. Watch what these people do and how they act and emulate that. Talk to them about how they approach life and listen very carefully to them.

Self-discipline often requires hard work, but few worthwhile things in life come easy. If you want to win a race, you have to run harder and faster than the other people. To run harder and faster, you have to condition your body, learn efficient running techniques, eat right, and when you become tired, you just keep on running. The same principle applies in other areas of life.

Q: i am a very hard worker,i study very hard,i practice n practice the things,even then during the exam i get nervous,i cannot even recall the important formulas which i would have used many times,revised many times,when this happens i feel very nervous,my heartbeat suddenly becomes fast,i get some sort of vomiting feeling,i am not able to know why the things i used to practice almost daily ,are not even rememred my me during the exam..n after the exam i come to know that this formula would have been used there n this thing i remember by myself only after the exam...sorry i am an indian,if there are any grammatical errors.bt please help me...my result is not good because of this..
One thing you could try is focusing on the easy parts of the test first (unless it's something like an oral exam where you must answer each question one at a time as it is given). This should help you to gain confidence and calm down for the more difficult parts of the test. On the harder questions, focus first on what you can remember and work from there. If it is a complex calculation, plug in the things you do know and work the parts you can recall, that should help your mind to remember the other parts.

Q: i am a teen, im an emo and i have been feeling depressed for the past 2 months. but in the 9th week i started getting suicidal, well mostly suicidal thoughts and i have been writing suicide notes and Wills for when i commite suicide. i am crying out for help on the inside. but i dont want anyone i know to find out about me. my parents would kill me themselves instead of getting me help, i want a painless way to die and a quick way to die. if anyone has suggestions than please tell me. i dont wanna live like this anymore. i CANT live like this anymore.
It would be irresponsible for anyone on this site to suggest methods of suicide or to encourage that as a solution to the things going on in your life. You really need to talk to a professional. A call to your local social service agency, mental health clinic, or hospital should put you in touch with someone who can help you or refer you to help.

I know you feel hopeless right now, but it's too early to give up on life. People do overcome depression and go on to lead fulfilling lives and I would hate for you to miss out on what could be a bright future. Your option to commit suicide will always be there, so why not put that off a while and explore some other options first?

You need help to work through this, so you need to talk to someone who can help you work through your emotions, so please call one of the places I mentioned earlier.

Q: Hi me and my boyfriend been together 5 months now. Well little bit over 5 months. We are both 20 we live in California. And I don't have a job and he lost his job, and cost of living is high, and we both been trying to look for jobs. so recently my boyfriend's cousin who lives in Tulsa, Oklahoma says cost of living is a lot lower. And he was like I might get a job through my cousin and leave to work so he can save up and spend rest of his life with me, and send a ticket when he has money save up. We love each other a lot. But we will separated for 5 months. which is hard for us. But guys have tips for long distance relationships? and how to get through it?
It can be done, but it is not easy. i wish my daughter were here to answer this as she hasn't seen her husband since January. He's in Iraq and she's in Korea in separate deployments. But let's see if I can make a few helpful suggestions. Number one is to maintain frequent communication. This is not as natural to men as it seems to be to women, so I am aiming this primarily at your boyfriend:dude, she needs to hear from you often, so make an extra effort. Fortunately this is easier these days with cell phones and the internet. Secondly, avoid temptation. Be careful of your contacts with single people of the opposite sex, when you're lonely and alone you're more prone to emotional entanglements and confusion or even outright cheating. And thirdly, make every effort to make your communication positive and enjoyable. Don't be superficial or fake, but do your best to ensure that your texts, letters, emails, or calls are uplifting. This will boost the confidence of the other person and will help to maintain the good feelings between you.


Q: Okay my ex boyfriend and I talks almost everyday we broke up like two times before but I can't Neva get him off my mind like he just always in Ma head I think he knows I love but I don't know how much though he does tell me he love me bac but I dont know if he mean it like he went out with my cousin but she passed but before she passed I tried back to have a relationship with him and it was all fine but he Neva texted me or called me I always had to do that I really don't know I just wished he knew how much I loved him so we had an argument a month or longer ago becuz I can't let him go but I tried to tell him but he Neva listeners I just don't know what to do is this really love ? Hope this isn't what it feel like !
I can't tell you if he loves you or doesn't. Maybe he does but is just poor at communicating, or maybe he just isn't that into the relationship, hard to say. But what is evident is that you are not getting what you want out of this relationship. Maybe it's time to cut your losses and start looking for someone who will be more attentive and communicative. It sounds like you have tried to talk to him and he hasn't responded. There are men out there who will give you the kind of attention you want, but you won't find them as long as you keep hanging onto this guy hoping to find the magic key that will transform him into the kind of guy you'd like him to be. Odds are he isn't going to change anytime soon, so it is up to you to decide how much longer you want to continue investing in this relationship.

Q: Ok ima 14 year old girl gone semi wrong. I haven't killed anyone or robbed a fricken bank at gun point, but iv befriended a 33 year old pedifile (dudes that rape kids), a rapest, and have gone onto sites I sooooooo shouldn't have been on!!! Iv got these voices in my head telling me to kill myself and in all honesty I hate my family, or at least a good portion of them. I'm planning on getting a dragon tatoo on my neck and acquire a taste for strong liquor. All im asking is how the hell am I supposed to get my act together? My grades have plummeted and so has everything else and informing out like my uncle and my dad that left befor i was born. Can anyone tell me how to straighten out???? Ppplllzzzz???
Ideally, you need someone to counsel and mentor you on an ongoing basis, because this isn't likely to be a quick fix. You have already realized that your life is spinning off in a direction that will end badly and want to get back on track, that's a good start. Getting your act together involves making healthy decisions that will lead to the goals you have in life. That means avoiding all contact with pedophiles and other sexual predators. It means paying attention in school. It means avoiding alcohol and other drugs. It means not listening to voices in your head telling you to do destructive things. These are the kinds of things that are going to steer you in the direction of a successful and fulfilling life.

It is difficult to do this alone, so I would suggest that you find a mature adult (preferably a woman)who is navigating life well to support and mentor you. Some possibilities include a teacher, school counselor, maybe someone from church, a friend's mother. It would also be helpful to speak to a mental health professional (counselor or therapist)if that is possible. If you don't know of anyone who can be a support person, try calling your local social services agency or a mental health clinic and tell them your situation. They should be able to help you find someone.

I don't know all of your history, but you obviously have a lot going on in your life right now. Associating with sexual predators, drinking alcohol, neglecting school, and surfing inappropriate websites are all negative influences. They are working against you, holding you back from your goals and dreams. You need to fill your life full of positive influences. Read good books, get educated, develop friendships with healthy people, get some therapy, engage in hobbies and activities which build you up, do some volunteer work helping other people. These things will make you strong; they will develop competence and confidence; they will connect you with people and resources that will help you to achieve success and joy.

Q: I'm 15 and I'm going into 10th grade I've been in high school for a year now and I go to a VERY small school...and everyone except for 3 people hate me because of one mistake I made 2 years ago. And I can't really apologize to someone because its everyone who hates me because of it. I don't want to go another 3 years with everyone hating me..I know there's always gonna be someone that hates me but I don't know what to do. I've always had very low self esteem and I've always thought I was really ugly and I don't know how to change it. I've gone to councilors and they haven't helped at all. I go in my room almost everyday I think about that mistake and I often cry about it.I don't know how to fix it and I don't know if I even can fix it!?!
You don't say what mistake you made, so I can't be as specific as I would like to be, but there are things you can do. If your mistake caused harm or offense to one or two people and everyone else is just dog-piling, start with the people you directly offended. Offer a sincere apology acknowledging that what you did was wrong and that their being offended is understandable. Ask them what it would take to mend fences. If your mistake directly affected a whole bunch of people, making up to all of them would be difficult, but not impossible. The best thing you can do, in my opinion, is to treat everyone with respect and kindness. Be open and friendly and positive. If you are consistent in honest, considerate, thoughtful behavior, people will begin to warm up to you.

Here's a secret: everybody wants acceptance, validation, recognition, and respect. If you can offer this to people (without losing yourself in the process), it will change people's perception of you over time.

I'm sorry you've found your counselors unhelpful. I wish they could have helped you see that if you think you are ugly and incapable, it's because you are looking at yourself wrong, measuring yourself by the wrong standards. You CAN have a bright future with a little guidance and perseverance.

Q: 16/f/India
Okay so I am in senior year. Here 12th grade is VERY important..My admissions into a good college will be only on the basis of the marks I score in my "board examination" which is held at the end of the year. The papers are not checked by my teachers but by some other teachers who don't know me and are teaching in some other school. This is done to make the examination fair. The cutoffs for any college where i live (new delhi) are CRAZZY. I mean nothing below a 475/500 is acceptable.
I have Physics, Chemistry, Computer science, English and Maths as my subjects.
Im telling you all of this just so that you know there is a lot of pressure to perform well.. and I have to in order to get a good college.
Ive just been real distracted for a while. I don't know how to concentrate on my studies. I dont feel like sitting with my books. It is freaking me out because every day matters to me. Please help!!!!!
If it helps. I havent been that bad in my studies. I wont say its cutting edge but then im one of the top 10 students in my class. Its just that i dont know how to get that extra edge..so that i can actually get into a college here. a very good college..
Make sure you are eating and sleeping well. Proper nutrition and rest will help you to focus. The brain actually does some important processing during sleep, so adequate sleep will not only help you to focus and be alert, but will help you to retain what you study. Give yourself permission to take breaks every so often. When you feel tird and fuzzy, get up, stretch, and walk around a bit. This will help relieve muscle aches and stiffness as well as stimulate blood circulation, which will help your mind to feel fresher. Being well rested and eating properly will also help you to feel more relaxed and alert for the exams.

Maybe change your study style every so often. Find a fellow student and quiz each other on the material for a while; maybe work out problems that have been giving you difficulty.

I took all of those subjects in school and found them all interesting in their own way. They can get pretty heavy at times, though, so you have my sympathy.

Q: listen last time i asked a question and i got some good answers now im back about the same guy now everything is worst. he says he loves me and that he wants a kid and a family. im already 2 months but the problem is that his ex girl of three years AND HIM STILL LOVE EACH OTHER HE LOVES ME AND LOVES HER AND IM CONFUSED....HELP!
Just because your boyfriend is confused and unwilling to make a decision and commit to that decision doesn't mean you should be confused. If you are the one who had to lie low whenever his ex was in town, then I think the situation is quite clear. You're involved with someone who shows a pattern where he does what is good for him. He breaks up with his ex, has a relationship with you, but is unwilling to let go of his ex, in fact, gives that relationship precedence over yours when convenient for him. He says he wants a kid and a family; wait, doesn't he already have kids? If you want to continue a life filled with this kind of drama, then this is your guy. If you want someone who will commit to you and build a healthy, stable family, this guy is nowhere near ready for that kind of adult responsibility.

Q: I am 20/f he's 26/m. This guy really likes me and we've been on two dates. I mean he came all the way from the other side of town to see me. See i can't date really, i know that sounds ridiculous but i can't tell my parents so i have to meet him in secrecy. Well anyways he wants to make it work from what he's told me. And well it's not really the whole my parents finding out, it's more i wanted a boyfriend for so long, and i was really boy crazy, but now i am just not sure i want that right now. I want to just want to focus on myself. He gave me an ultimatum saying i should just tell my parents, lie to them, because he really wants to make it work, and i am just not sure. So what should i do?
You're afraid to tell your parents about your relationship with this guy. That seems rather odd for a 20-year-old. You are an adult, after all, and it's hardly an unusual thing for someone of that age to have a romantic relationship. What would they do if they found out about your dating a boy?

This guy is pressing you for a relationship, even to the point of lying to your parents because HE wants to "make it work"?

I wonder about your statement of the problem: "I am scared to be with him." What's the scary part? Your parents' reaction, this boy's rather aggressive approach to the relationship, or the prospect of putting off dating/romantic relationships for a while to work on yourself?

I can't tell you what to do, but a relationship which involves secrecy and lies is not off to a promising start. I'm reading between the lines here, but this guy sounds like he's putting a lot of pressure on you to do things that are likely to benefit him far more than they will benefit you. Let me just say, if you can't do something with confidence that it is consistent with who you are and what you want in life, proceed with extreme caution.

Q: So, I dated this guy for a few months but I've known him basically all my life. To put it simply, he's a horrible person. He loves to fight- I mean LOVES it. We didn't live in the same town so when he would go to parties on weekends without me (I had to work), he or his friends would call me saying I need to calm him down because he got into a fight literally EVERY WEEKEND. He would always instigate it, and he'd always win. He also was easily angered by me, and would call me a slut or accuse me of things I didn't do. So here's my problem: Although I broke up with him several months ago, I've noticed I have a horrible temper now. I think because I was always having to defend myself, or pretend I didn't care, or act like I was strong when I wasn't.. now I don't let anybody in. I don't know how to start caring more about the people around me. I used to think it was a good thing that I didn't take crap from people anymore, but now I'm starting to realize I've become cold and when somebody does something I don't like, I tell them. And when little things happen, I get way more heated than I should. How do I learn to calm down? And how do I learn to have better relationships with people?
You have made a good start by recognizing your behavior. The best advice I can offer is to take a purposeful approach to your relationships. Picture yourself as a calm, confident, caring person and picture how that kind of person interacts with others, then practice interacting with people that way. If you need help with what that looks like, observe other people who have those characteristics and emulate their behavior.

Talking to a therapist or a couselor would also be helpful as he or she can help you gain insight into the cognitive and emotional roots of your current state of mind. Coldness is a defense mechanism, for instance. Overreacting in anger is rooted in a sense of threat. If a person taps you on the shoulder you turn to see what they want. If your shoulder is sunburnt, you're likely to yell at them. The gesture is the same in both cases, but in the second case pain resulted in an angry outburst. When you overreact to little things, a very similar thing is happening; a relatively benign gesture, statement, or event touches something painful in you and you react to the pain. A counselor can help you sort through these things.

Q: umm, well im 13,female. and i got really drunk with a couple of friends. And my mistake happened, i had sex and we didnt use a condom, but i didnt get pregnant. i really liked this guy, we were talking for 6 months.am i slut for letting this happen ?
A one-time event doesn't make you a slut. It's a useless label anyway. Even if you did fit the definition of a slut, how would applying that label be in any way helpful?

Please take this event as a wake-up call. You are too young to be drinking and having sex. Continuing that sort of behavior will only lead to trouble. Soon enough you will be old enough and mature enough to both drink and have sex in a responsible way. It's a lot easier to get into trouble than to get out of it, and some choices have life-long consequences. Enjoy your teen years, but please be careful so you can also enjoy your adult years.

Q: I am currently in a bad relationship and have been for two years now. This is one of those first love high school sweetheart relationships that wouldve been awesome if it lasted forever. To make a long story short the fling began in '09 at the time he was cheating on his girlfriend with me and thats how it stayed for a year then they broke up and we got together and hes been doing the same thing(lieing and cheating) on me for a year. I knew i had it coming and i know what i did wad wrong so i accepted my karma but with that being said i dont think anyone should have to be punished for the rest of their lives but he just wont stop he always says he will i always believe him and he always does it again but i love him more than my own family more than my life itself and i just wont let go. How much is enough? How will i ever learn to just let go? I dont want to feel this pain anymore im tired of crying myself to sleep every night. I need a solution. But how can you let go when the thing you're holding on to is what is keeping you going everyday?
Maybe you need to find something else to keep you going every day. It's fear and insecurity that keep you hanging on. Trouble is, you're hanging onto something that is holding you back. It's keeping you from moving on to healthy relationships and a healthy sense of self.

How much is enough, you ask? You passed that point long ago. This guy is lying to you, cheating on you, and causing you pain. You cry yourself to sleep every night. You describe your experience of relating to him as "punishment". Please tell me what it is you are getting out of this relationship that is worth the misery. What is it about this abuse that "keeps you going every day"?

This is not,karma, this is you hanging on to a false security. You will never find happiness, contentment, support, and joy in this relationship. Your feeling of love for him will eventually turn to hate, but in the meantime considerable damage will be done to your psyche. Every moment spent in this relationship delays a healthy, happy relationship that much more. Every moment spent in this relationship further damages you in ways that will make it more difficult for you to find and enter into a fulfilling relationship.

Find someone who is emotionally healthy, strong, and mature to support you in breaking away from this guy. Possibilities include: A teacher, school counselor, therapist, a church leader, a family member or relative who has demonstrated success in relationships, preferably a woman in all cases.

It's scary to leave the familiar for the unknown, but for you the familiar sucks. There is much better out there, and letting go of this guy is the first step freeing you to go out and find it.

Q: So this guy I've been talking to for the past couple weeks is really different than the rest of the guys I've ever known. I'm kind of "defensive" you can say when it comes to guys because I've had some bad experiences but he says he understands and isn't a douche and that I can trust him and he wasn't going to ditch me. He reminds me a lot of myself. And he had hinted at us being a "thing" quite a bit. I told him some of my darkest secrets and he could relate to them and was understanding. I feel like the last couple days I was being really, really clingy because I always ask like when we are going to hang out again. He's been sick and I was aware I asked it a lot and it sounded clingy but I just thought eff it. It really isn't something I do and not like myself.. I know it was really stupid. But after I asked yet again he started using like one word responses like "naaah" and "noo" and I asked what was the matter? And he said "nothinnnn." So you know he was annoyed. So I stopped texting him. Now he hasn't texted me at all today. And I don't want to text him because I don't want to be annoying.. SO what can I do to fix this? I really don't want to just stop talking to him now.. but what can I do?
Give the guy a chance to take a breath or two. Guys generally don't communicate the same way girls do. They don't feel the same need for constant emotional communication that girls often do. I can't speak for all guys, especially being of an entirely different generation, but I would find constant texts to be an annoying distraction, especially if it interrupted a conversation or activity I was engaged in at the time. I wouldn't get too worried about going one day without texts from him.

Back off a little. Keep in touch in a fun way a couple times a day. You don't have to stop talking to him, just don't smother him. Relax and enjoy your time with him; again, have fun and don't be overly "emotionally demanding". If the guy enjoys his time with you, he will want to be with you.


Q: So ive been in love with this guy for over a year. we have dated a couple times, but have always stayed involved. we are pretty good friends and he knows im in love with him. and i dont think he loves me back. which is fine with me, he doesnt have to love me back. but he told me he wanted to go back out, and was really sweet about it and everything. but i told him to give me a few days to think it over. so while i was thinking he went and slept with some chick i hated in the first place (i despise her now). hes always doing stuff like that. like hooking up with me then asking someone else out the same day. i know it would be smart to stop trying and give him up for good. but i love him with all my heart. hes the only person who makes me genuinly happy. and i would do anything, be anything for him. what do i do? continue to give him my heart or try to move on? and if i should move on how? how do i stop loveing him?

-female, 16
Here's the deal, if you stick with this guy, you will eventually come to hate him, and probably yourself, too, for wasting your time with him. You're in love with a fantasy version of him. Sooner or later you will fully wake to the reality that he is a manipulator, a player, and at times spiteful.

You need to gain some self-respect and stop allowing any man to treat you this way. There are men out there who will treat you respectfully. The only man (really, to be honest, he is merely a boy and has a LOT of growing up to do) who makes you genuinely happy is someone who hooks up with you when it is convenient for him, and also hooks up with any other gal that happens to be convenient at other times? That's sad. I think you need to explore why you find someone so appealing who treats you with such disdain.

Q: So Im completly in love with this guy who lives in California. But I live in Iowa. And he loves me. We've always wanted to be together and we've talked everyday for over a year now. Awhile ago he told me he has had suicidal thoughts but said he would never do it cause someone made him believe if he committed suicide he would go to hell. So I didnt worry. Recently we've been getting into a lot of fights due to jealous and stuff. And all of a sudden his suicidal thoughts are back. Once he told me we should talk as friends, and I told him if thats what he wanted then I would agree so I could let him be happy. But then he said he wanted to stop talking to me overall because he said it would be too hard. Then he kept telling me "Its over" "Im done" "Its really over." And I could tell he was talking about his life. I dont get it because Im just going with what he wants? We've been through this so many times but its getting to a point where Im about to crack. I dont know what to do or say to him to keep him to no longer think suicidal when it comes to me it seems like. Please please help.
It is not your responsibility to keep him from being depressed or thinking suicidal thoughts. He needs to talk to a professional about these thoughts. You may be the focus of his suicidal thoughts, but if it is a genuine suicidal mindset, he would fixate on someone or something else if you were out of the picture. Urge him to get help from someone qualified to deal with his issues. You are not equipped nor are you in a place where you can "fix" his issues. Bottom line is that there is nothing you can do or say to keep him from being suicidal. Even if you had some magical power in this regard, it would still be a sick, codependent relationship.

He really needs to talk to a pro: a therapist, a spiritual leader, a local mental health professional. A call to Social Services, a local clinic or hospital, or a suicide hotline will put him in touch with people that can help him.

Q: im the girl who wrote about the boy thats going through all those phases and what not, yeah maybe your right,hes not mature enough.. he used to be, i just dont know what happend,hes the only guy thats ever treated me like this.. like when hes grit oeat hes great,when hes bad hes bad =/ i just dont know whether he'd regret it or not, wev been through alot, he says im theo nly thing in his life that keeps him happy, and now he says he feels better without me =/ i just really am having a hard time, he always said we can NEVER break up, and that hed never break him promise, but i got so mad and said what i said, and he knows i didnt mean it, but his excuse of doing what he wants now is that i broke up with him, and its all my fault =[
He sounds like he likes to have his cake and eat it, too. He likes to have you as a constant in his life that he can always fall back on, like a security blanket, while he goes on and does what he wants. A healthy, committed relationship involves considering each other's needs and sometimes not doing things you would like to do for the sake of the relationship. It's convenient to blame you for the failure of the relationship. A relationship, by definition, is what happens as the result of the actions of both people involved in the relationship. He's doing what he wants now because that's what he wants to do, it's not "all your fault" that he's doing what he wants to do.

I don't know all the dynamics of what has happened with the two of you. It would be interesting to get his perspective - how he views things that you have done and said. But here's where the problem of maturity comes in. He does what he wants, but it seems to be based on impetuous reactions rather than reflection and honest communication and decision making.

Maybe it's time for you to move on. There are other men out there. I know you've invested 2 years in this relationship, but maybe it's time to cut your losses. Maybe he'll regret his behavior, maybe he'll grow up in time, but I wouldn't get back together with him before he demonstrated a more honest and mature approach to relationships; one which involves consideration for what "she wants" and what "we want" as much as what "he wants".

Q: I have come to realize that what I had thought to be a one night stand while I was drunk came to be more. I have somehow developed feelings for the man I had intercourse with. He is a pastor buddy of mine and we share the same beliefs. I am married with kids and Not really sure what to do.
I really dislike the limitations of text. This situation is best served by dialogue in "real time", but I'll do the best I can with this format.

Let's look at this in a somewhat different light for a moment. How much different would this situation be at its core if this pastor buddy were a woman? This kind of situation happens all the time in a heterosexual context. A man is friends with a woman and they come to a moment of indiscretion and things happen and then there is emotional confusion and guilt as well as other fallout. How would you counsel someone in that situation? My guess is that you would not advise him to "follow his heart" further into trouble. You would advise him to disentangle himself from the affair and to go about the business of building up his marriage and his family. You would look hard at the factors that led up to the affair and address those issues. Truthfully, the dynamics of your situation are not significantly different from those of a heterosexual affair. That's not to say there aren't a couple of extra twists here, but the answers are pretty much the same.

What's at stake, here? There is tremendous potential for damage to your family, your ministry, and your friend's ministry if you allow your feelings and confusion to guide your actions. So, at the very least you need to step back and go "whoa! What's happening here?" You need to gather your wits about you and plan your next moves with a cool head. This means avoiding contact with your friend and avoiding situations which would feed this "affair". You have a wife to whom you made vows, you have a family for which you are responsible, and you have a ministry involving the oversight of a number of souls, and for all of these you will answer to God. This is about way more than what you think you may want in the heat of a given moment. Which is why it is so vital to "get your head on straight" right now. Again, this is less about the possibility of your having gay tendencies than about sexual behavior, romantic entanglements, relational responsibilities, and obedience to God in general. In fact, it goes to the very nature of sin itself. One homosexual act is hardly the sum total of all the base urges within your being that would love to express themselves. Just in the sexual realm, many men succumb to the temptations of affairs, porn addiction is rampant even among Christian men, pedophilia and other asymetrical relationships are becoming more evident all the time. Hardly a week goes by without a story in my local paper about someone caught with child porn on their computer or a coach having an affair with a student. These specific situations are merely slightly divergent manifestations of man's basic urges, weaknesses, and failure to exercise good judgement and self-discipline.

Now, if we were sitting in the same room, having a conversation, I would engage in a probing dialogue about what's happening in your marriage and family life right now. I would look at the sequence of events that led up to the incident with your friend. I would look at the things all this tells you about yourself which would help you walk into the future with clarity. I would look into your faith and relationship with God and look to what it will take to reestablish it on a firm foundation.

For now, let me speak to your last few words, "not really sure what to do". First, you need to talk to God and repent of this sin. Once again, the homosexual nature of this encounter is only secondary to the fact that it was a sexual encounter outside of marriage. Regardless of what you or I or society thinks of homosexuality, this was an act of adultery and is therefore sin on that basis. Then you need to ask God to restore you in Him. No matter what decisions you make, the road ahead is going to be difficult and you're going to have to walk it closely with God if you want to navigate your way to victory.

Secondly, you need to avoid feeding the temptation, which means disciplining your thoughts and avoiding contact with your friend. It is best if you can find someone mature and trustworthy in whom you can confide and who can lend you strength and support in doing the things you need to do, and in not doing the things you need to not do. Someone who will build your faith rather than undermine it.

Thirdly, you need to be proactive in building on the positive. What I mean is, much of what you need to do involves restraint and discipline, which can be draining. Invest your energy in your relationship with your wife and children. Invest it in restoring your relationship with God. Invest it in those things which will build strength in you and the things you value, and in the things God values.

I'll stop here for now. This should be enough to chew on for the time being. In the meantime, I will be praying for you.

bio
Rumely

Info
Gender:
Male

Location:
Minnesnowta

Occupation:
Mail Processing Equipment Mechanic

Age:
51

Member Since:
May 30, 2011

Answers:
76

Last Update:
April 25, 2014

Visitors:
4762



layout by Adam Particka

<<< Previous Advice Column
Next Advice Column >>>
humorist-workshop

eXTReMe Tracker