So my boyfriend had a party last night, and a couple of hours before he went he decided to call me. The call consisted of me asking him if he would please please skip any flirty, snuggly, huggly, kissy dares, because he had been very liberated about that, even when we're together.
His response was basically that there was something wrong with me, that I wasn't all right with that. That "no-one else seems to have that problem but you". Followed by "Why can't I be with you, AND have fun?"
I then asked him how he would feel if I had my lips pressed up against someone elses', and he said he wouldn't mind, which tore my heart out.
He kept repeating "I don't want to ruin everyone's night by chickening out of a dare just because I have a girlfriend", and "why does it have to be either A or B with you..hy does it matter if it wouldn't mean anything anyway."
I'm just very hurt right now, that he doesn't see kissing as a special thing that I only want to share with him, and he replies with "you've been with plenty of people and kissed them too." which is true but only before we got together.
I'm just extremely upset and hurt. Is this normal? Am I over-reacting?
WittyUsernameHere answered Sunday May 15 2011, 8:44 pm: Here's the thing. You're both right.
Some people's jealousy focuses on emotional intimacy, some people on physical intimacy, some people (a small number) have no manifest jealousy at all.
Your boyfriend's comment of "it's not like it means anything" is telling. It doesn't, to him. He values emotional intimacy. If you kissed another guy because you were playing truth or dare, he wouldn't care. He trusts that you are into him, and he isn't threatened by a kiss that involves no actual love or affection.
You have an issue with the act of kissing itself. It is special to you in a way it isn't to him. That's something that feels right to you because it's what you want, and it's what pricks your jealousy. You're not wrong, but you have to recognize that this is something that you want, not something that he is wrong for not wanting.
This is a gap between the two of you. It is something you must discuss (calmly) and compromise on or realize you can't. He is not wrong for wanting the freedom to have fun when it means nothing and is no threat to the relationship. You are not wrong for wanting him to respect your boundaries.
In this case, you two have to decide togther whether your relationships is the thing that's wrong here.
He's not doing anything that I think you should be threatened by. But if you can't help it, consider whether trying to deny his freedom to have fun to make yourself feel better will do more harm than good.
This will come up in other ways. If you were both adults I might have a little more of a "he should compromise to respect what you want" opinion but at 17 he's still a young guy and wants to have fun like a young guy. He isn't looking for a girl he has to hide these things with, he wants to be able to go play truth or dare and talk to you about it, laugh about it. Maybe bring you along and play it and laugh when you awkwardly kiss another guy or sit there hoping you have to kiss another girl. He wants to not care so much and relax where you don't.
Can you date a guy like that? Should you? Are you right for him and he right for you? At 17 the answer to that is no, so the question before you is do you want to relax or do you want to break up and find a guy who thinks more like you do? [ WittyUsernameHere's advice column | Ask WittyUsernameHere A Question ]
Jackieee answered Sunday May 15 2011, 7:53 am: Surely, I don't think you're overreacting at all. I would be very hurt, as well.
First off, truth or dare is ALL about those kinds of things...so you should avoid the game in general, unless you want it to end on a bad note with your boyfriend.
The fact that he nonchalantly said he wouldn't care if you kissed another guy in front of him (whether or not if it meant anything), signals to me that he might not value your relationship. And if he is telling you he doesn't care if you kiss someone else, he could be doing the same thing to you, and you might not even know.
His reaction is very suspect and I, for one, absolutely would not trust him. Who knows what he could be doing to you? You need to have a serious sit-down talk with him about valueing your relationship as a couple (and no third parties, whether or not it's just truth or dare) OR maybe you need to walk away from him until he can mature and fully take on the responsibility of a relationship instead of being concerned solely on "truth or dare" which is very childish of him.
Don't let him turn this around on you. So you've dated other guys before and obviously you've kissed but not in a cheating fashion, so what? Your boyfriend is incompetent and he needs to change or you need to get our of your relationship, because it seems to me that he WILL cheat on you (in front of you or not) or HAS already.
Attention: NOTHING on this site may be reproduced in any fashion whatsoever without explicit consent (in writing) of the owner of said material, unless otherwise stated on the page where the content originated. Search engines are free to index and cache our content. Users who post their account names or personal information in their questions have no expectation of privacy beyond that point for anything they disclose. Questions are otherwise considered anonymous to the general public.