The poem has a bit of interest to it, but right now I'd call it journal poetry: A good self expression for the person who wrote it but not particularly impactful or meaningful for others who read it.
The repetition of And I said, And you said, aren't helping you. They are ruining the flow of ideas. This poem is difficult to read, because it is written in sentence form it’s choppy and unpleasant on the eyes.
When writing poetry there are two pieces advice I like to give. One, show us, don't tell us. Don't tell us that "When I looked in the mirror, and tears slid over the face that no longer belonged to a child" Give us an image instead, something more powerful and more true, like "The creases of age make paths for new tears across the face" or some such.
Advice Two: Destroy unnecessary words viciously. Poetry was once described to me as “The fewest, best words, in the best possible order” If a word isn’t helping you along, it’s hurting you. For example, if were to rewrite a few lines for you I would write instead
“I wasn’t sad. I didn’t weep for you
You wouldn’t have wept for yourself”
Good-bye unnesicary words! Keep only the ones you need.
Give it an edit love; it’s not a bad start at all. Just remember poetry doesn’t need to obey the rules of sentences or grammar, it only needs to obey them enough to be understood.
schlichtinator answered Sunday February 11 2007, 9:24 pm: Think about what message you're trying to send across - Why should this poem be read? What specific emotion or revelation did your experiences evoke? Your goal as the writer should be re-creating that experience for the reader. [ schlichtinator's advice column | Ask schlichtinator A Question ]
karisue answered Sunday February 11 2007, 9:23 pm: i agree with Bbeautifulbby555.
it wasn't an amazing poem that made my jaw drop, but it didn't make me want to instantly exit out the screen either.
it was a little hard to follow & was kind of odd, but as long as you know what its about & you know why it is the way it is, then what anyone else tells you shouldn't really matter. [ karisue's advice column | Ask karisue A Question ]
Attention: NOTHING on this site may be reproduced in any fashion whatsoever without explicit consent (in writing) of the owner of said material, unless otherwise stated on the page where the content originated. Search engines are free to index and cache our content. Users who post their account names or personal information in their questions have no expectation of privacy beyond that point for anything they disclose. Questions are otherwise considered anonymous to the general public.