I have been in my current relationship for 9 months. Previouisly my relationship was 4 years in which we had a child. since then her father hasn't seen or talked to her in 6 months. Now when she starts to get close to my boyfriend she takes three steps back. But if she meets someone new she walk with them and hold their hand and she won't do this with my boyfriend. This upsets him and I've told him maybe she's just afraid to get close with himbecause she's afraid he will leave her too. Please help me try to understand this better. (she's only 5 years old)
[ Answer this question ] Want to answer more questions in the Relationships category? Maybe give some free advice about: Families? xxMoxx143 answered Wednesday July 20 2005, 10:03 pm: ya i agree with you that she might be afraid that he will leave her but it also might be that shes afraid if she gets really close to your boyfriend and you marry him and stuff like that that she will never see her father again you can always just ask her be like sweetie are you afraid hes gunna take daddys place or are you afraid that he will leave us she might be five but shes not stupid hope i helped
babyygqirlx3 answered Wednesday July 13 2005, 2:07 pm: Hi. I can help with this one. My parents are divorced and my mother remarried a guy who is a total asshole. I know I am a lot older than your daughter but I went through the same thing. Your daughter is acting like this because she is affraid she will get attatched and then he will leave like her father. Also because she is affraid that he will hurt you, kids are like that sometimes because they are very protective when they are little. But if I were you, sit her down and talk about him. (not when he is there) then try to find a solution so you can feel more comfortable.
Susan answered Wednesday July 13 2005, 9:08 am: Please give your daughter time to adjust. She may just be 5, but she has feelings and understands the differnece between strangers and people whom are in her life. It's only been 9 months, your boyfriend should understand as he is the grown up and she's the child. Don't pressure or force your daughter to go to him, she'll go this when she's good and ready [ Susan's advice column | Ask Susan A Question ]
ElmosBrightStar answered Tuesday July 12 2005, 11:04 pm: My parents divorced when I was 4, and I went into depression. She will talk and things with strangers because she knows that she won't get too close where they might leave her. She IS scared that your boyfriend will leave. Tell him that she needs time, and then talk to your little girl, and let her know that her daddy didn't mean to hurt her, and that your boyfriend doesn't want to hurt her and it's okay to get close. Also let your boyfriend know she is sensitive. Then, try to get her father to see her. It's hard not seeing your father. My dad moved to Connecticut and I saw him 2 times a year. It's hard on kids, because they don't understand the concept of one parent, when everyone else seems to have 2. Just give her time, she'll come around. After all, she is only 5. Trust me, I was the same way with my dad's girlfriend. [ ElmosBrightStar's advice column | Ask ElmosBrightStar A Question ]
TheTeenGirl answered Monday July 11 2005, 9:22 pm: Your boyfriend needs to stop pushing it. Your daughter is only five years old and he needs to think more of that fact. Have you ever thought that maybe since her dad left that she will get close to anyone but your boyfriend because she feels replacement has been taken from her fathers' place also? I think its your boyfriend who needs to understand better. He sounds too impatient for this kind of situation, I'm not asking you to dump him, but you need to say, "look, shes had a rough past with her father, and you're going to have to wait for however long it takes for her to get a healthy relationship with you." Your daughter is just going through difficulties with her past, its not abnormal in anyway, even teens get like this toward their mothers' new boyfriends. And five year olds can get upset about these things, shes so little and had to handle a big past. So, I hope you can tell your boyfriend to calm down, because your daughter probably needs your hand to hold right now when it comes to this problem.
twistedsister17 answered Monday July 11 2005, 8:32 pm: Well, it probably feels weird for her. Shes only five years old. The best solution I can think of is for him and her to spend more time together. Still, she might not understand it, shes only five years old. [ twistedsister17's advice column | Ask twistedsister17 A Question ]
Scribble answered Monday July 11 2005, 6:02 pm: I think your first assumtion is probably right, but its also possible that she is uneasy about your boyfriend because of his relationship with you. She's already had one parent disappear for reasons unknown and may be afraid that your boyfriend will take you away too. By remaining cold towards your boyfriend, she may be attempting to keep you all for herself, so she won't be left alone. Just a thought. [ Scribble's advice column | Ask Scribble A Question ]
punkette501 answered Monday July 11 2005, 5:01 pm: .....well maybe you have to tell your daughter that this guy is ok and he wont hurt her....but i dont kno if she is old enough to under stand that so maybe have him baby sit her or have a day with him so that they can get to kno each other...she maybe shy at first but she will warm up to hi...dont worrie....hope i helped...bye [ punkette501's advice column | Ask punkette501 A Question ]
Attention: NOTHING on this site may be reproduced in any fashion whatsoever without explicit consent (in writing) of the owner of said material, unless otherwise stated on the page where the content originated. Search engines are free to index and cache our content. Users who post their account names or personal information in their questions have no expectation of privacy beyond that point for anything they disclose. Questions are otherwise considered anonymous to the general public.