Boyfriend tells me he hates me but doesnt want me to leave
Question Posted Monday July 13 2015, 3:06 pm
My boyfriend has had trust issues with me. He believes I violated him multiple times with the same issue, which I have, in a way, with another guy. You see, I'm in a little local band within my community and one of the members and I were close friends. I went through some problems with the "boyfriend" I have now and the other guy was just trying to be a good friend to get me through it. He eventually started to develop feelings for me. I told him I didn't like him like that or would ever see myself with him. At first he was upset. (He wasn't too fond of my boyfriend, though we're all in the same group together) But he eventually got over it and told me he'll be there when he needs me. My boyfriend was furious that I even let the other guy into my life to try to turn my mind away from him. We had lots of issues, my boyfriend and I, and he was being really neglectful. He left the state for months to get away from me at the start of our relationship, when I thought things were getting better. When he came back permanently, I welcomed him back with open arms but he told me that I had to give up talking to the other guy completely. Tell me if it makes sense that for someone who I have to see all the time, I should stop talking to him completely? For someone who's done nothing but be there for me, I had to stop talking to him. His only mistake he ever made was falling for me. And he knew it. But my boyfriends hatred for him never went away. I did speak to the other guy on occasion behind my boyfriends back, because I knew I was doing something wrong but neglecting him. My boyfriend doesn't see it that way. He threatened to leave every time he found out we've been talking. Some drama happened within the band lately and it was sparked by me unintentionally (lesson learned) and I carried some news to the other guy. My boyfriend learned of it and hates me now, says I never stopped talking. Thing is, he said he doesn't love me anymore but doesn't want me to leave him. Says I have to try to gain his love again but he doesn't expect it will happen. He curses and me, calls me names, taunts me, tells him I'm worse than dirt but he doesn't want me to leave him. My boyfriend isn't perfect, he has a LOT of faults in himself, many which have been pointed out by other people that I've seen for myself and yet I still love him. Even with him being nasty and rude to me, I still love him. I know you will say I shouldn't stand for it but I want him to love and trust me again. It will take time. Am I wrong for still having faith? He will make me suffer for it but I think I deserve it. I left the band and so did he and others for drama reasons. I don't know what to do. I hate myself so much for what I did and my bf has even supported my hatred in myself. What do I do?
[ Answer this question ] Want to answer more questions in the Relationships category? Maybe give some free advice about: Love Life? forever_gone13 answered Tuesday July 14 2015, 12:47 pm: I understand that you have feelings for this guy, but he honestly isn't worth your time. Women are not to be considered "property" like they were back in the older days, and he's breaking this rule by treating you like he owns you and you belong to him. It'll only get worse if you stay with him. A woman deserves to be respected, and he apparently doesn't get that because he's too immature for relationships. You're an amazing, intelligent, beautiful young lady her deserves to be treated with respect. He's trying to play a game that he knows he'll never let you win at, and he's only playing it so he doesn't have to give you up.
Razhie answered Tuesday July 14 2015, 8:03 am: You boyfriend is controlling, jealous and emotionally abusive. He made an unfair 'rule' that ignored everything you wanted and believed about your friend and the rest of your life and friends in the band, and then he punished you when you didn't blindly obey him. Now, he's trying to manipulate you into 'proving' your love, while all the time telling you that you'll never be good enough, and that he'll never love you again.
Also, he doesn't want you to leave, because deep down what eh really wants, is the excuse to go on controlling and abusing you.
So you dump the boyfriend.
You may have made mistakes, but you don't have to be perfect to deserve a boyfriend who doesn't verbally and emotionally abuse you. Nothing you can do will EVER mean you deserve to be abused by someone else. If your boyfriend was really that unhappy with you, if he truly thought you were cheating and dishonest, he'd dump you. He probably knows you are loyal. He's probably not that unhappy, because he is getting what he really wants: An excuse to be abusive. To keep you scared, desperate and isolated.
Escape. Get away. It wont take time to heal this. Your boyfriend has made a choice and he's very unlikely to change that choice - he's even told you as much. He's chosen to abuse you. He is chosen to hate you. He's doing everything he can to make sure you accept the abuse, and hate yourself as well.
You will learn to forgive yourself, and love someone else, but you will never learn that if you keep submitting to his hate. You do need to heal, but first you need to get away from the person who is hurting you. [ Razhie's advice column | Ask Razhie A Question ]
missundersmock answered Monday July 13 2015, 9:46 pm: Ok you have some reflecting and looking inward to do here.
ask your self, how long can you put up with him treating you like that just to gain his love back which (as he said himself) may not even work? a week, a month? a few years?? thats a long time isnt it??
How much do you value yourself and your own happiness?? because its GOING to get taken from you if you stay with him i can almost assure you of this because he wants you to stay so that i can control you, and isolate you from others around you. Trying to make you no longer talk to people that you dont deem as a threat to you isnt "his feelings being hurt" its called him trying to use love as a leverage to get you to do what he wants. You sound smart and like you already know the answer here, you just dont want to admit it to yourself which can be hard i know.
You shouldnt hate yourself for still wanting to talk to a band member, you need to tell him right off the top that YOU will make the call on who you choose to talk to and who you dont. its YOUR life not his, and he has not right to rule your social life in ANY aspect.
HE IS however allowed to let you KNOW how he feels about someone, and you can then reply back that you will "consider his view on this person" but unless this person crosses a personal boundary with YOU and your body then YOU will make that call and if he cant handle that then he can walk.
Trust me on this, this kinda shit always starts with him just wanting for you to not talk to one or two people and then grows exponentially over time and ALWAYSSSS uses things he knows will hurt you against you. you need to be strong and confident and law down the law with this fool, or else this kinda thing will just get worse and he will box you in and box you in until you find yourself without friends and lonely because of him.
many people think that they can make their partner their WHOLE happiness and that could not be further from the truth. If you do that, youll always be let down because we're all human, we have flaws, and because we are "afraid of being alone in life" we "settle" for whoever will toss a little "love" our way (and i use the term love LOOSELY here because it sounds like he doesnt really love you at ALL) and like hes more in this for the sake of having control over another person.
ask yourself WHO THE heck wants you to do what they say in order to appease them but makes no promise that they will love you again?? what kind of a person DOES shit like that??
im sorry for the harsh words but ive seen way too many of my friends go through this exact same situation before and i really do feel for you here. you HAVE to get yourself out now because if you dont, he will make you feel so down on yourself that youll think your not worth more and you ARE! you deserve to be happy and make your own choices! life is too short for BS like this, and im sure you dont want to go from having one parent who told you want to do as a kid to ANOTHER as an adult.
Attention: NOTHING on this site may be reproduced in any fashion whatsoever without explicit consent (in writing) of the owner of said material, unless otherwise stated on the page where the content originated. Search engines are free to index and cache our content. Users who post their account names or personal information in their questions have no expectation of privacy beyond that point for anything they disclose. Questions are otherwise considered anonymous to the general public.