askBehnnie
advice column ask question view feedback favorite columnist advicenators

Q: im confused about what to do with my ex cody, its like i get the hot and cold responses from him, so to speak. sometimes he's extrememly nice and we flirt and get along GREAT and others he seems completely shy and doesnt talk to me.

i have liked him since august (it now being january) and in august when i told him that he said he liked me too. so he kind of dragged his feet .. not sure what he wanted .. didnt know waht to do . the usual guy thing. and when i'd finally given up hope on him and me he left me a message at midnight on october 10th like three months later sayin he wanted to give us a try. only to dump me 10 days late b/c he he liked someone else .. then he told me a couple weeks later that he wouldn't have dumped me for her if she hadn't had a boyfriend ..

so that was like november .. now its january and the guy is still all i think of. i try so hard to get over him .. but like around every other corner hes either makin me fall for him again or his friends are being COMPLTELY honest and telling me stuff he says.

like shawn told me that they talk about me all the time (he wouldnt say what but he said the stuff worked in my favor) and that in our study hall (me him and cody have it together) he cant wait for me to come out and talk to them .. and i asked him to stop jokin around w/ me and he went off sayin how honest and truthful he was being ..

then new years cody called. he came and got me on his snowmobile. me and his brother and friend hung out from 9 to 3. we hung out. watched fireworks in the barn by ourselves. hung out around the bon fire. laughed constantly and flirted. i thought it went great .. i had like good hopes you know .. we fell asleep on the couch then they brought me home. he said he'd call. yeah a week and half later .. no call. we talk at school . nothing big hey and how are u kinda stuff ..

i know its probably worthless to waste my time .. and you can be completley honest in tellin me so. but like even though my head knows that .. i cant let go .. 5 months later .. jesus look at me .. in so far i cant even get out .. i've never fallen for anyone like i've fallen for cody. he tells me he can see us dating in the future but doesnt do anything about it .. i just dont know what he wants .. its like this i guess to explain it well ..
It's like a routine.
I fall for him on Monday.
I like him from Tuesday to Thursday.
He make me mad on Friday.
I think I'm over him over the weekend.
But the SECOND I see him on Monday morning
I fall for him again and again
i just dont know what to do ..

so now that i've finished my freakin book .. im sorry its soo long. i just want all the details in it .. sorry sorry sorry.
alyssa05x@aol.com .. if you need more info or something doens't make sense.
i really appreciate it and im sorry about the length .. thanks in advance
First off: how old are you Alyssa? What year are you in school?

Sorry for the delayed response. I work pretty long hours and by the time I get home I'm totally wiped :) But I really wanted to respond to your question because even though I might not say anything that helps, I know that sometimes for me I feel better just knowing that someone is listening and is at least thinking with me about what's going on.

Okay, if you and Cody were in your twenties or something, I'd say that he sees that you're a person worth being interested in. That he really likes you for who you are, but that there seems to be part of him that's still looking to date around and have adventures and some guys think they can't have adventures when they're "tied to a relationship." [Not all guys think this way! My boyfriend can't wait to marry me so we can have adventures together!! But he's also a lot older than Cody and probably wouldn't have felt the same way when he was in highschool either I'm sure ;)] I'd say that he obviously has feelings for you, but that his preference for doing his own thing is so strong that it's keeping him from seeing what a wonderful girlfriend he could have in you so he's going to keep coming back to you when he needs to feel appreciated, and is going to keep going after other girls when he feels confidant enough to "pursue" adventures of that kind...

I'd say "Alyssa: Next time he's flirting with you, or treating you in any way that's more than how he treats his other female friends, you ask him why he's doing it. Ask him what it is that he wants from you. Force him to think about it, and to say it out loud to your face instead of through friends, before he goes confusing your heart any further. And if he keeps playing that game, let him know you're not interested in playing it. That it's confusing and it's just keeping both of you from pursuing other relationships that could be a lot healhtier and in which you'd know the person you were with really wanted to be with you and wasn't just biding their time until someone else came along that they wanted to "try out." And if he says he wants to be with you, then tell him okay. He's your friend- give him the benefit of the doubt. And the first time he goes back to playing the game of now-we're-together/ now-we're-not, tell him you're not into playing those kinds of games, be strong, and end it for good."

That's what I'd say.

I'd encourage you to be tough, even when he's being super-sweet and his friends are saying that he talks about you and likes you. I'd encourage you to be solid in your words and decisions, even when he invites you over and treats you like his girlfriend. Because he needs to either make the decision to be your boyfriend, or make the decision to just be your friend. But he can't have it both ways at the same time. You're not his toy- you're his friend. And friends treat each other with respect or else-- or else what's the point of having friends? (Bearing in mind that friends last much longer than dating relationships which tend to ruin friendships 9 times out of 10...)

On the other hand, if you and Cody are in your mid-teens...

I'd say "He's clearly too young to be so involved with somebody and shouldn't be dating anybody anyway, let alone dating YOU since you're obviously a bit more aware of other people's feelings when it comes to *liking* and the importance of communication and dealing with friends' emotions when it comes to situations where it's so easy to unintentionally hurt people.

I'd say "Let him keep playing around like young boys do, but make it clear that you don't want to play around with him. That's just so "summer camp melodrama." Let him know you still like him and you'll date him if he's interested, but that if he can't make up his mind and has to date other girls and be hot and cold with you, you'll make the decision for him by moving on.


thanks =) that helps alot. he promised me we'd hang out this weekend .. so i guess we'll see how things go from there .. if we have fun im gonna ask him straight out what he wants from me .. friends or more .. i cant wait forever .. so it either work out and hell say he wants a relationship .. or (given some of his current past) he may just blow me off all togther .. but ill move on i guess .. thanks what u said really helped me think

bio
Behnnie

Info
Member Since:
January 1, 2006

Answers:
41

Last Update:
March 3, 2008

Visitors:
4425

Favorite Columnists







layout by Adam Particka

<<< Previous Advice Column
Next Advice Column >>>
humorist-workshop
eXTReMe Tracker