askTanDancer
advice column ask question view feedback favorite columnist advicenators

Q: 18/f

I'm in college, and I want to get my roommate something nice for the holidays because a lot of us are exchanging gifts. All of us, except for her, celebrate Christmas. She grew up in a Jewish household, so she celebrates Hanukkah.

Would it be okay to still get her a "holiday" gift. Would I just write Happy Hanukkah on the card?

We're doing a secret Santa, too. Should we invite her to participate or just leave it since she doesn't do Christmas?

What's the etiquette for that?
I would research Hanukkah (I personally don't know much about it), and get her something that shows you made an effort to understand her point of view. I imagine that her family still exchanged gifts, so it would be more than appropriate to get her a gift.

You should definitely invite her to play secret Santa as well. Even if she doesn't believe the religious aspect, she probably wants to be included in her friends' celebration. At worst, she'll simply decline. Most people enjoy being included in their group of friends, and they are very hurt when they are left out.

If you are really concerned, you can talk to her about it, and ask about her beliefs. She has dealt with Christmas her whole life, so she probably knows what she expects. So just ask her!

Good luck and much love!

~TD

Thank you!

bio
TanDancer
I'm back after a hiatus! I have graduated college (yay!) and am working with Thoroughbred racehorses in Kentucky.

I enjoy giving advice to teens because now that I am older, I have a proper perspective of high school, but I am close enough in age that I don't think I'll come off as some idiot with adult problems that has no idea how teenage life works. Generally I answer love life questions, since that is where many self-image problems surface-not to mention it's highly confusing! If you are wondering about my own love life... well, I have been with my current boyfriend for 5 years. We are getting married once he finishes law school, and yes! We are high school sweethearts!

I also love giving advice to dog owners. I have grown up with dogs and currently have two mutt-butts of my own :) I have worked for several different veterinary clinics, including a vet school, I have taken tons of classes, as well as doing personal research.

I try to be understanding of everyone's problems...I also try to see things from the asker's point of view, but often I do not have enough information so I do the best I can!

BTW if you want to ask me a question, please keep in mind: I LIKE--decent spelling and grammer, proper punctuation, and real words; I HATE--using "like" improperly, lack of punctuation, and gross misspellings. I am happy to read and answer any question, but these are just polite things to do for any columnist!

Info
Gender:
Female

Occupation:
Shadwell Farm Intern

Age:
21

Member Since:
December 15, 2008

Answers:
73

Last Update:
March 30, 2010

Visitors:
4537

Main Categories:




Favorite Columnists





layout by Adam Particka

<<< Previous Advice Column
Next Advice Column >>>

eXTReMe Tracker